And so here we are in Holland and before I start today can someone please explain to me why the Amsterdam Intercontinental Hotel needs to know Heidi’s and my date of birth, occupation and our combined household income…….do they need to know this before Ingrid the hotel maid steward changed the bed sheets and poured bleach into the toilet to remove the remains of dinner that were doing their Klingon impression?
Why does the hotel’s registration form need to know…………before the girl would give me our room key………… how many and which types of credit cards I have, the month that I renew my buildings, contents and car insurance, the ages of my children and whether I own my own home? Why does it use capital letters to emphasize that I should reveal “ALL” the leisure interests and activities that I enjoy and the gob smacking impertinence of it….. Whether I have shares, savings plans and other investments.
What does any of this have to do with the quality of the eggs I will eat for breakfast? It’s a stupid bloody question, obviously.
The point is to pass this precious, private information on to other retailers so that I’ll be blitzed with spam and junk mail which will build behind my front door and give more viruses to my computer than if my laptop were to sleep with a Latvian hooker.
Anyway, I answered most of the questions but when it got to the part about salary, savings and credit cards I scribbled away but what I was actually writing was that I was wearing white underpants …………….and that I hated the French.
I am always conscious here about what I write and although mine is an independent blog that I do represent Carnival Cruise Lines and that I have, regardless, become part of their customer service program……and therefore I have to be careful what I say………….who I ridicule and who I make fun of……..because the last thing I want to do is have a country and western star write a song about me………..let me explain.
I was watching CNN this morning here in the “We Know Everything About You Intercontinental Hotel” while Heidi got Kye ready and cleaned up the Grey Poupon that had erupted into her diaper and I saw a piece about a Ms Irlweg. Her full name remains a mystery. All I know is that she lives in the Chicago area, works for the customer relations department of United Airlines, and has become the subject of a new country and western music video, which has been posted at some point over the next week or two on YouTube.
You see, several months ago, Ms Irlweg had the misfortune of handling a passenger complaint from a man named Dave Carroll, who happens to be a Canadian musician. This chap had been flying on United when he saw baggage handlers throwing around his guitar case on the tarmac outside, and when he arrived at his destination; it turned out that the neck of his beloved $3,500 Taylor guitar had been snapped like a turkey’s leg at Christmas. But when he asked for compensation, he was told to bugger off by department after department, until finally he reached Ms Irlweg, who at least gave him a straight answer.
“No………bugger off…………….eh”……….she’s Canadian so I had to add the “eh”…….because that’s the law.
I am sure he had a few choice words to say to Ms Irlweg but he also, according to the CNN bit I saw this morning, told her he was going to write three songs about his experience with United Airlines, shoot videos for each of them, and then post them online…….what a load of bollocks, she must have been thinking. ………….oops.
Because our Canadian Garth Brooks kept his promise. The first song according to Uncle Google, United Breaks Guitars, has now been played over 3 million times on YouTube, become a smash hit on iTunes, and has resulted in Carroll’s star to rise.
Meanwhile, within four days of the song going online, the gathering thunderclouds of bad PR caused United Airlines’ stock price to suffer a mid-flight stall, and it plunged by 10 percent, costing shareholders $180 million……..which I am sure the president and men with beards at United now realize would have bought poor Dave about 20,000 replacement guitars.
Meanwhile poor old Ms Irlweg has become a symbol of what we all experience at some part of our lives……….bad customer service.
And so I pledge once again that here on my blog thingy to give you the best possible customer service and be kind and decent to each and every one of you…..except Ruth and Al G, who having read this and thinking that I am Carnival’s equivalent to Ms Irlweg are probably already at their local karaoke bar to record their new hit music video called “John Heald Is A Total Bastard And His Underpants Smell.”
Here is the link to the You Tube video all about Ms Irlweg…………..poor thing
And for no other reason except it makes me look at myself and know I need to lose weight ……… here is a video ….from YouTube of me…………dancing……………those with a weak disposition, pregnant women and anyone with diarrhea…………should look away now!
And now to continue that good customer service, here are more questions that I have been asked to reply to……………..here we go.
Mike Asked:
Hello John (please do reply),I was wondering, whatever did happen with the couple from Holland? We were hoping to see an end to the weeklong proclamations of love at the final show, but that never happened. What did Ivona end up receiving?
-MikeJohn Says:
Hello Mike
For those who have no idea what you are talking about let me just quickly say that I had a couple from Holland…………..where I am now……..who were taking part in a skit throughout the cruise. I had promised them some prizes which I was to present at the debarkation talk but unfortunately Mike as you would have seen they were not at the talk. Afterwards I discovered that both had awful colds and were in their cabin and so I went there and gave them their prizes which included a diamond and sapphire pendant, a watch and lots of goodies in a big bag…….they were very, very happy. I hope you had fun that cruise and I hope we have fun together again on another Carnival cruise.
Best wishes
JohnFrank and Bridie Rist Asked:
John please respond,
We still hope and will make sure you don’t forget about having lunch while you’re on the dream here in Port Canaveral? I’m sure Linda and Mike won’t let you forget either.Thanks, and looking forward to meeting you,
Frank and Bridie (Big fans)John Says:
Hello Frank and Bridie
I have not forgotten and I look forward to seeing you both and Linda and maybe a few others next year.
Best wishes to you both and see you soon
JohnMarty Paul Asked:
Hi John (please reply),
I bet you are happy to be home with your beautiful family, IKEA trips notwithstanding.I am a religious reader of your blog (daily) and love it. Also, my girlfriend & I are booked on the Oct 15th sailing of the Carnival Dream in the Med.
However, I just had a quick question about the Carnival Glory’s 2010 Canadian itinerary. Did Carnival cancel the 3 “After the Glaciers” cruises to Quebec City?
My girlfriend is French Canadian (easy John, French Canadian is different than French), and there is a certain big question I plan on asking her on a gondola in Venice, so I was actually looking at sailing on the Carnival Glory to Quebec City and possibly getting married there!
Can not find these cruises anymore on the Carnival web site, so I’m afraid Carnival must’ve cancelled them? Is yes, why?
Thank you,
Marty PaulJohn Says:
Marty:
Wow…….you old romantic fool you……………being proposed to on a gondola in Venice is every woman’s dream ……and some men’s dream as well. It will be a very special moment and if I may recommend that you do it at night when the inner waterways are candle lit and that you should pop the question by the Bridge of Sighs which local legend states will bring you years of happiness and loads of rumpy pumpy.You are correct that unfortunately we did cancel the Quebec cruises and that is a real shame as Quebec…….despite the French influence……….is a beautiful city. I am sorry about this but if you have any other ideas or need my help maybe you could let me know. Maybe 2011 will bring some exciting new itineraries for you to choose from…………keep checking the blog and I will let you know.
Have a wonderful cruise on your Carnival Dream and maybe you can send me your cabin number a couple of weeks before you sail so I can send you an engagement gift.
Best wishes to you both
JohnCharlotte G. (not related to Ruth G) Asked:
Dear John, – Please Reply
Thank you so much for the pictures of the Carnival Dream and the cove balcony rooms. My DH (dear husband) has booked 2 of these rooms for our family – in May. We are surprising our 19 & 22 year old children!! (DD & DS)We have adjoining cabins. I had read where there would be permanent dividers between the balconies; therefore our family would not be able to combine balconies, however, when looking at your photos, it looks as if the dividers are indeed removable. Do you know if they are in
fact removable? (Or is it just wishful thinking on my part)Either way, I am looking forward to a wonderful cruise. Thank you so much!
Fondly,
CharlotteJohn Says:
Hello Charlotte G not related to good old Ruth G
I am so glad you have been enjoying the photos of your Carnival Dream and I am sure you were excited to see your cove balcony cabins and actually I am not sure if you can open the dividers. Having seen them I pretty sure you can’t as I think the dividers are in a permanent fixed position. Anyway, please allow me to check with the ship and I will let you all know ASAP.It will be a wonderful cruise and what a wonderful surprise for your family. How lucky they are.
I will let you know the answer to your question soon.
Best wishes to all
JohnTina Asked:
John please respond
We will be sailing on the Carnival Splendor Oct. 11th 2009 for our 20th wedding annv and my in-laws 50th annv. Is there a way to request a certain cabin steward? We sailed on the Carnival Splendor in May of 2009 and we really liked our Cabin Steward her name was Maliwon she
did a great job and she was a sweet heart. She said she’d still be on in Oct. but she did not know which deck she’d be on. So is there a way we can request to have her again?
Thanks
TinaJohn Says:
Hello Tina
Whereas I can help with the dining room seating requests assigning specific crew members to guests is not something I can really help with. Let me explain. Each stateroom steward has their own sections to look after and each steward is often assigned a section of a deck for their entire contract. However, I will pass this on to the ship and who knows………you may get lucky. I will also let the Housekeeping Manager and Hotel Director know that you enjoyed her wonderful work and that I know will make her very happy. I will ask the Housekeeping Manager to have her stop by and say hi.
Have a great cruise
Best wishes
JohnBrian Asked:
John, **PLEASE REPLY**
Around the first of Aug I sent a question and you said to give it 7 days and someone would be in contact with an answer…still no answer.My questions were basically….
If I booked a cruise, and later (weeks) the same type cabin drops in price, can I request a reduction in my cruise fare, or do I have to cancel the cruise, wait for the credit card refund and rebook.
I am a platinum cruiser, and in addition to the cruise fare being reduced, they are giving better/larger upgrades now than when I booked (ex: 4A – 4G).
Unfortunately now, my final pay date has passed, so cancelling is not an option. But for future reference, it would be good to know. Plus, I would hope that platinum–or even all past guests –would get best possible upgrade.
Thanks for your time!!
BrianJohn Says:
Hello Brian
I am so sorry that nobody has contacted you and that is something that I have been able to improve on these past weeks. This is due to the fact that I now have a dedicated team to help me and this CARE Team is led by the wonderful Vicky Rey who I will now write to and we should indeed hear from someone very soon. Please let me know how the call goes and my sincere apologies for the delay. Thanks for your loyalty to Carnival and I hope you continue to read the blog thingy.
Best wishes
JohnSusan Little Asked:
John, please reply…
My husband and I plus 10 of our friends are joining you on the Carnival Dream, Oct. 3/09. Everything has been going pretty smoothly until this past week when we hit a major snag. I sent our info for a tux rental for my hubby on Aug. 19th and didn’t hear anything for a week so I started checking and calling. I was told they were not renting anymore tuxes for the cruises in Sept. or Oct. My one friend had already booked hers and paid for it only a short time before me and since they advertise that you need to book at least 2 weeks before the cruise I assumed that 6 weeks out was a pretty good bet. I haven’t managed to get my husband in a tux since we got married and was really looking forward to having pics done in his “monkey suit” as he calls it and was very disappointed in the outcome of my quest. Why wasn’t Carnival prepared to supply enough tuxes for rental? They tell me the shop on board will have some but it is a first come first served basis and my husband is not exactly a small guy so the chances of obtaining
one seem slim. Has this happened before or have their suppliers changed? Please help me out here in understanding why I and several other couples are being disappointed with this decision. Thanks for your help.John Says:
Hello Susan
This is all news to me. I was not aware of this until I read your posting. However, I did some checking and have been told by the department that runs our Formalities shops that we had some supplier issues with our tuxes on the Carnival Dream’s European sailings but tuxes will be available once the ship gets to the states. This I know that this doesn’t help you much but I did want to pass this along. Fret not – we really don’t see a lot of tuxes these days and your husband should be OK with the elegant night recommendations. Wish I had a better answer and thanks for taking the time to write.
Best wishes to you and your husband.
JohnJoesakic1999 Asked:
dear john please respond,
let me start out by letting you know I would never call you by your other name uncle toilet that is just wrong’s have just returned home from the freedom and I want to let you know you have ruined cruising for me sari know what your thinking but no I mean in it in a good way I don’t think I could ever go on another cruise without huge expectations from the cruise director after experiencing such an amazing job by you. I was on the mystery cruise and you were nothing short of brilliant. First off I emailed you ahead of time and you secured a table for 2 in the dining room for my mother (more on her later) and I and for that I thank you. we went to the marriage show and I didn’t stand up and you asked who was next to me and why wasn’t I standing and I yelled it’s my mom and you said she looked young so you didn’t know and for that she thanks you. We enjoyed you so much, mornings on the lido watching you on the big screen, the shows, Holland, dick little everything was so great that we got our voucher for a future cruise. We were hoping to say hi to you in person take a picture or something but our paths never crossed, till next time that is. ok enough of the arse kissing onto the questions.im weighing in on the kids, I
know carnival is a family cruise but there has to be some control on them ,kids were running everywhere past employees and nothing was said, I’m not saying they shouldn’t be allowed on the ship but neither have free reign to do whatever they want. and I respect that you asked the parents to try to help but let’s be honest they are happy to get the kids away from them so they don’t care as long as they are not with them. so here’s a question does it even matter what time of year I go on my next cruise or are there always tons of kids or does it ebb and flow depending on the school year? And does destination make a difference? Speaking of destinations I loved the beaches of Tortola and St. Thomas but didn’t like the third world atmosphere when we were in other parts of the island and with your many years or experience are there any destinations that for lack of a better word are more upscale then this itinerary? What is your favorite warm weather itinerary.wow this is a long post 2 more quick questions I promise. I really enjoyed your efforts on the cruise and I know you would never accept a tip but I would like to recognize your efforts so do you have a favorite charity that you would like me to donate to as a token of my appreciation? And finally I swear, where can I get an autographed john heald in a thong photo? thank you so much for your continued effort with the blog, enjoy your time with your lovely wife and baby and if you need to add somebody to your small list of friends I’m here for you, thanks for everything mike from Vegas….oh john please also reply I forgot to ask one other question in my long diatribe earlier, can you get me a date with Jaime or Mel on the freedom? And not Jaime Fraser the singer the other one her and Mel are hottttttttttttttttt. Ok I know I have no chance but as cruise director you can make anything happen, right?????? J/k….thanks again mike in Vegas….
John Says:
Hello Joesackic1999
What a wonderful review and let me start by saying how proud I was to read your comments on how much you enjoyed the cruise and that I made such an impression on you….I am truly humbled.Let me address your concerns as well. First of all the kids. You sailed with a under 18 count of nearly 1,000 and that of course means that nearly one third of the passengers are made up of that age group. While the majority of the kids are well behaved there are some who do run around and as for controlling them………….well as much as we can do onboard it is surely the job of the parents to tell the kids what they can and can’t do. However, on the other hand Mum and Dad do know that we at Carnival provide the safest of vacation environments and therefore they feel comfortable allowing their kids to roam free. Some have suggested a curfew for children which I must be honest I am not a fan of. We are a family cruise line, an affordable excellent value line and that is something which we know will attract families. No, a curfew is not what we need to do. What we do need to do is catch the tiny percent of the kids who act up. Did you know that the cruise you were on some little bastard carved some kind of graffiti tag into the elevator doors?
You can always expect a high count of children during June, July and August and during other holidays like Easter, Christmas etc. The rest of the year the count is lower ……..maybe an average of between 100 and 200.
As for the ports it is hard to think of a Caribbean port of call where poverty does not exist. Maybe Grand Cayman, St. Kitts and one or two others but like all countries there are always going to be those that have and those that have bugger all. My favorite warm weather cruise is still the western Caribbean including Grand Turk, Ocho Rios, Jamaica, which certainly has its fair share of poverty and you must see the very luxurious private island of Half Moon Cay.
I remember you and Mum well from the Marriage Show and I am so touched by the fact that you would like to donate some money as a thank you. That really is not necessary……but if you want to give a little something than maybe you could donate to the charity that Heidi and I support as much as we can and that is Save the Children whose work basically is to protect children from poverty all over the world. Here is their link.
https://secure.savethechildren.org/01/in_honor_of_special_person_undes?source=hp_do_gift
As a thank you for this I have arranged dinner for you and Jaime at your local Burger King.
Thanks for sailing with us and my best wishes to you and Mum.
JohnMike Charters Asked:
John please reply
We’re booked into a 4F on your Carnival Spirit next September to Alaska and then to Hawaii. I’ve been trying to find out if the patio door in the room opens or not. I’ve seen reports both ways. Could you please ask the current CD for us? Thanks!John Says:
Hello Mike
Thanks for taking the time to write and having checked with Lui the Guest Services Manager and he confirms that although a 4F cabin does have a obstructed view due to the lifeboats the doors do indeed open.
Hope this helps
Best wishes
JohnRob Petrillo Asked:
Hi John (PLEASE REPLY)
I happened to find your blog by accident and have really enjoyed reading it.My first ever cruise was on the Carnival Victory to Nova Scotia a few years back. We really enjoyed it except for the vast amounts of “unsupervised” kids running amok. We couldn’t enjoy the pool the entire trip. Now this is mostly the parents fault since obviously on vacations they don’t have to be parents and supervise their kids. But nobody on the crew seemed to mind or say anything to kids that run up and down the halls and decks push all the elevator buttons and do
constant belly flops in the pool.Don’t get me wrong, we love kids but my wife is a teacher and looks forward to a vacation without having to feel the need to discipline someone else’s kids.
We have since taken 5 other cruises on another “Royal” line mainly because of their adults only solarium (pool, hot tub area) which is really peaceful. We also didn’t experience the “kid amok” factor anywhere as much as on our one Carnival Cruise.
This December we have decided to go back to Carnival for a New Years Eve Caribbean cruise. To be honest, it was mostly because the dates worked out better for us. But I also want to see if we just had a bad kid week that one summer on Carnival.
We are, by coincidence, on the Victory once again for a 7 islands in 7 days cruise. Sounds exhausting without any sea days, but yet exciting at the same time.
My questions are:
What happens on the Victory during New Years Eve? I’m sure there is something special done.
How many formal nights will there be? Not sure if New Years Eve falls on a scheduled one or if another one will be added.
Do you know of where online I can read recent Capers for this itinerary?
I do not mean to come across as anti-Carnival because on our Nova Scotia cruise everything else was wonderful. The food, entertainment, activities and crew were all great.
Thanks in advance.
RobJohn Says:
Hello RobI am glad you found the blog and it’s strange that your first posting should include a question about kids onboard. I think there are always going to be kids who do not listen to their parents and do run up and down the corridors regardless of what ship they are on. I remember a post a few weeks ago that I replied to that said the problems you encountered on the Carnival Victory were ones they encountered on an RCI ship. You only have to walk around your local shopping mall to see groups of kids as young as 12 running around doing what kids do these days. This is certainly not an excuse and I promise you that our staff do care and we continue to look to improve in controlling the kids and hope that parents will help us as much as possible with this …………by the way………pressing the elevator buttons is something I probably would have done as a kid.
Anyway, I am sure that your New Years cruise will be brilliant and that the kids onboard will be well behaved and I will promise you that our staff will do all they can to make sure they are.
There will be two formal nights including New Years Eve after you leave St. Lucia. I will ask the CD when he intends to have the other one. There will be a huge party planned and I know that it will be a most fantastic way to see in 2010. The party will mostly take place (weather permitting) on Lido Deck and will feature champagne, live music, the countdown and lots of surprises.
I am currently working on getting the Carnival Capers for each ship posted here on a permanent site for the blog thingy. At the moment we do not have a way to publicly see current Carnival Capers and it would be great if we could.
Please, never apologize for sharing your views, thoughts and opinions here on the blog even if they are of a negative nature. This is an open forum and I am honored that you and so many many others take the time to do so.
I hope my answers have helped you a little and if you have a follow up please let me know
Best wishes to you all
John
That’s all for today. There will be more tomorrow.
Let’s have a look at one or two of our sister companies blogs which as usual contain some fantastic photos and information for all who love the world of cruising to enjoy.
Let’s start with Seabourn who as you will see from their blog are once again the proud winners of yet another luxury travel award. You will also see some great photos of the amazing suites on the Seabourn Odyssey…….congratulations Seabourn and here is their link thingy……….pop on over and have a look.
http://blog.seabourn.com/
And you must see the Holland America’s site because Nieuw Amsterdam’s funnels arrived Wednesday, Sept. 2, on a barge towed by a tug from the manufacturer Nuovo Arsenale Cartubi in Trieste, Italy, to Fincantieri. There are great photos of this right here:
http://www.hollandamericablog.com/
Now, that is in fact the perfect link to our guest today, a man who is responsible for all the refits within Carnival Corporation…………..so as I know many of you are fascinated by what happens during a refit………..here is an interview with a man who knows………Mr. Peter Fetten.

Peter, welcome to the blog. Please tell us all about you and the extraordinary job you have at Carnival Corporation.
My name is Peter Fetten, SVP corporate ship refit, I’m married with 3 children, 2 boys one daughter, the youngest is still studying at FIU, Miami. Originally I’m from Germany, Hamburg, I’m a naval architect and worked at a shipyard, Blohm and Voss, for 14 years in several senior positions, I came to the US with my family in 1997, at the time having my own consultancy company and mainly worked on the development of Grand Bahamas Shipyard in Freeport, which was eventually built in 2000. From 2000-2008 I worked as VP Newbuilt and fleet design in RCCL, Finally I started to work for Carnival in the new position in July 2009, and I’m proud to be part of this fantastic company now.
In my 30 years in the new building and repair and conversion business I mainly worked on cruise ships, starting with classic ships like the QE2 and France/Norway and being part of developing several prototypes of cruise ships, lengthening, widening, revitalizing, adapting and modernizing ships throughout my career either as project manager or leader of a team of project manager.
And what does your job involve.
My job involves every aspect of ship refit, starting from idea/concept, feasibility/benchmarking, planning, milestones, design, vendor/yard selection, execution/project management, and start up as well as guarantee follow up.
Let me clarify, we will support the brands in one or all aspects of the above, we have a team of 4 person here in Miami (Jeanine Rodriguez, Lisa McCape, James O’Shaughnessy and myself) (plus 1 member in Genoa, Italy, Franco Portolaccia), and work as an integral part of the brand project management. Be aware two hands and one brain cannot do this, it’s a team effort.
Before we talk about the projects you are currently involved in, can I ask your opinion on why refits and redesigns are so important these days within the cruise industry
The refits are an integral part of a ships life, the design is based on certain itineraries, markets, trends, functionality, earning capabilities, age etc. If any of this parameter are changing the ship might have to be adjusted for the new requirement, further the new ships which are coming out have a lot of update features and amenities, which drives the upgrades of the older ships, to deliver the same ‘Brand promise’. Whatever the reason is, each of this upgrades are unique and challenging, since it needs to be done in the shortest possible time.
Peter, please tell us about the current Corporation projects you are working on and what work is being carried out
There are a lot of exciting refits presently in planning or execution worldwide, CCL is refitting Carnival Ecstasy this year and Carnival Fascination next year. The main focus is on adding around 100 balconies, a new water park, and pool deck upgrades, a full makeover of the main public areas, and extensive technical upgrades. Fascination has a similar upgrade in January next year. The Carnival Holiday will be ending her service for CCL in November and will be transferred to Costa/Iberocrucero, and will undergo a complete rebranding/ refit from top to bottom.
HAL’s Rotterdam later this year will add a new aft superstructure and a new aft pool experience with a new outside bar and several new balcony suites. Further extensive renovations and upgrades throughout the ship will round up this refit.
Ocean Village 2 will be rebranded in November in Singapore for Carnival Australia, which involves a lot of upgrading work in the public areas, new tender boats etc.etc. There are of course numerous other projects in the feasibility or evaluation phase, which I can report on at a later stage.
Which of the projects you mentioned has been the most challenging and why.
The challenges are on all projects similar, the time is always too short and the work scope is always too big for the time available. The logistic challenge is always there, since most of the materials and vendors are from Europe and wherever we do the refit it needs to be brought to the yard in the right sequence, and environmental or other ‘high balls’, like strikes, hurricanes, shipping limitations and 1000 other possibilities of disruption are our day to day enemies. A big refit can have up to 400 containers of tools and materials which need to be available just on time for the contractor/yards to do their jobs. Not to discuss the endless ‘surprises’ which needs to be managed every minute, especially at the execution phase. One thing is guaranteed it is not getting boring.
What is the reward for all this hard work?
The reward for me is coming from the team spirit in this ‘crazy times’, where everything needs to happened extremely orchestrated, and the team manage the unbelievable last push before the first guest come on board, and are able to laugh and contribute to another story which nobody will believe anyway…..
The Carnival Sensation, Carnival Fascination and Carnival Ecstasy will have or have had new balcony cabins added which have proved to be very popular. I am sure this is a very complicated project but can you simplify the process and tell us just how this is done.
This balcony project requires a lot of detailed engineering work, since we are adding ‘cut outs’ for the balcony doors. The cut outs are in the side shell, and the strength of this side shell is reduced by the ‘cut outs’. We need to compensate this strength reduction by replacing the existing thinner shell plating with new thicker shell plating and stiffener. Further we need to have a new platform (balcony) added. This will be done by prefabricating new side sections, which will be inserted into the old removed (to thin) shell sections. This is very complicated and need to be very accurate, but since time is of the essence, it needs to be prefabricated by the yard before arrival of the ship. After the steel (structure) is ready welded, we need to install the balcony glass railing, divider, light, drains, deck covering door , window and not to forget the cabin need to be modified from the inside to allow the comfortable and safe access to the balcony. I heard several time the question, why are we only putting the balconies in the middle and aft section of the side and not on the whole side, the answer is on top, we need to be able to lower the lifeboats still safely into the water, and the balcony would obstruct this operation, except in the areas where the new balconies are installed.
And so we kind find out more about you……please fill in the blanks tell us your favorite:Car: 1956 Packard Panama Clipper
Ship: Seabourn Odyssey
Drink: Franken White wine (Boxbeutel)
TV: Discovery Channel
Dessert: Vanilla ice cream with strawberriesAnd if you could refit any existing ship in the world……….what ship would that be and what would you do to her?
Refit a smaller cruise ship and ice strength it, to allow her to go through the North West passage and operate safely in the Arctic and Antarctica. Good Zodiac boat platforms for exploration and landing on the ice. This will be only for 120 to 150 guests. But could be very unique and a once of a life time experience for the guests.
What a great interview and remember when you walk on a ship that has had a major rejuvenation that the man who helped breathe new life and in the case of the Carnival Fantasy class, new fun, into it was Peter. If anyone has any questions for him please let me know as I know he would be happy to answer them for you ……………..thanks again Peter.
We will return with a brilliant Cruise Director interview tomorrow.
So Todd and the entertainment staff joined your Carnival Dream on the 4th of September. I emailed Todd for his first impressions of the ship…………….all he could say was
WOW!
I know how he feels………………do you?
Let’s have a look at some photos of your Carnival Dream cast rehearsing one of the shows that will also leave everyone as Carnival shows always do…….saying WOW while on their feet applauding.





I am not sure which one of the three new shows this is from but I can’t wait to see for myself.
Tomorrow, updated photos of the stunning atrium………have you booked yet?
So Heidi and I are in Holland and the joy of her family seeing Kye and the sorrow of taking her to Heidi’s Dad’s resting place has meant a day of truly mixed emotions. It was a good trip over though on a Stena Line Ferry which left Harwich, Essex just as we did on the Carnival Legend in 2002…………..so many memories.
Just to continue the kids on board theme for a moment as it was so relevant to today’s Q and A I just wanted to add a few more comments. I will start with the fact that we must empower our staff to stay vigilant and look out for those who are going beyond the line of having fun and are doing things that will disturb others vacation time. However……….it seems that in most aspects of life today the younger generation has changed so very much. The music they listen to, the TV they watch, the games they play and the ability to know about anything thanks to the internet. I was trying desperately to think of an example about this and really couldn’t think of one until Heidi reminded me about our milk man.
In the UK we still have something from the old days. A man who delivers the milk who is cleverly called………………the milkman. When I was a kid, our milkman was called Bob and used to whistle as he came down the path with our milk…………..it was always the same tune……….the theme from The Bridge Over The River Kwai.
However, fast forward 40 years and the milkman who last week delivered our milk. He was a spotty 18 year old wearing a baseball cap on backwards.
It was the day he collected the money we owed for a week’s worth of milk……….usually something Heidi took care of but now I had answered the door. He handed me an electronic thing to sign with no good morning and no whistling. As I signed his gadget and paid him the cash I heard a terrible noise from his milk van which was outside my house, in my quiet suburban street, with the windows open and this loud, aggressive rap booming from it: “I’m gonna **** you, bitch! Yeah, you’re my bitch! Yeah slap my bitch!”
I couldn’t believe it. I mean , suppose he had been delivering Kye’s gift to my Mum, or your Mum or to a house that had kids who were old enough to hear the words I’m gonna **** you, bitch! Yeah, bitch! Yeah bitch!”…………..and think it’s ok for them to say the same thing to their math teacher Miss Dickinson …………..the next day at school.
So, as a new Dad I know I have to be the best Dad I can be but…………because I don’t want Kye to be running up and down the corridors of the Carnival Magic pressing elevator buttons and stealing Southern Dreams electric scooter and listening to “slap my bitch.” on her Eye Pod…………I intend to impose the following rule of law which I now have the honor to pass onto all the parents out there.
1. Give your child pocket money as early as you like but take a bit of it away for every crime they commit. If they are really naughty, dock a whole week’s payment — so they owe you. Then take a favorite toy into custody as security on the loan ………if they don’t pay up………set fire to it.
2. Every house should have one, a “naughty spot” where children are exiled for bad behavior. Make sure they can see everyone else enjoying themselves while they sit alone. My naughty spot for Kye will be in front of the TV forcing her to watch the Teletubbies, Barney and Dora the bloody Explorer……..surely that’s punishment for anyone
3. If they won’t get dressed in the morning, take them to school in their pajamas. Once should do it. Carry their teddy bear in your arms if you haven’t already burnt it (see number 1)
Kiss them goodbye, then press your nose against the classroom window while blowing soppy kisses — and also waving the teddy bear. Threaten to do the same each time that they are late getting ready for school………..even if they are 15.
4. There is a place where you keep valuable or dangerous belongings. The children should be of the firm and unmovable belief that it also contains child-munching goblins from France who will eat them for breakfast.
Yep………..I guess as we get older what kids do these days does seem strange. Even police officers, schoolteachers, government officials and presidents of Costa Cruises all seem younger, and I’m finally staring down the barrel of my 45th year. ….bugger.
The answer to naughty kids is to me very simple……………. ……… give them a good clip around the ear……..just like we got, right?
I remember once that Mum and Dad took my sister to a hotel for a holiday in the west of England ……………a very special treat indeed.
However, as an 11 year old my overriding memory of that holiday was not the beach or the rollercoaster rides but my Dad’s shoe on my arse. That was because I decided to have fun with a toilet roll. I went into our hotel bathroom, tucked the end of the toilet paper roll into the back of my underpants and saw how far I could get through the hotel before it snapped…………quite far actually………………..right up until I was reprimanded by an employee………..and that’s when my arse had a close encounter with my Dads size 9.
Children will always be welcome on a Carnival cruise…..99.9% are wonderfully behaved but………if one of the naughty buggers does steal an electric scooter…………Mums and Dads……threaten to introduce them to your shoe……………I promise they won’t ever do it again.
Goodnight
Your friends
John, Heidi and Kye
Look, friends — there are a few things you should remember before you comment. The space below is for you to post your comments about the post I've just written above. If it is something that's unrelated, please use the Ask John tab above. Now, while I may not be able to reply to your comment below, I do sit in my underpants almost every morning and read everything that is here. So feel free to comment on the comments and then if someone wants to comment on the comment to the comment then go ahead as well. Please be courteous unless the poster is French...........then you can say whatever you want.



























Hi John, Another gread blog. You are waisting away to nothing. You look great.
I made the final payment on the former (November 15th) bloggers cruise. We are going anyway. Couldn’t pass up a Carnival Dream cruise out of New York. Are you going to be on any days of that cruise?
Jo and Dave
I hadn’t heard about the United/Guitar story and when I played the YouTube everyone in the office thought it hysterical…. BUT NOT SO MUCH as when I continued and showed YOU!!!
Thnx for making 10 females laugh so hard that we cried… Even Heidi was laughing!!!
But, we still love you….
Hmm why do I think that a funny bit now for the welcome aboard show would be john walking up and down the showroom with a long roll of toilet paper attached to his bottom.
Big fans as allways,
Frank and Bridie
Please, please, please John offer my thanks to Peter. His department has done a magnificent job with refitting the Fantasy class vessels. As you know, I was on the Fantasy after her refit, the Inspiration after her refit and I’ll be on the Ecstasy in the spring after her refit! I can’t wait to book one of the new balcony cabins!!
How can it be that Carnival can provide such masterful customer service at such a brilliant price point when companies that expect you to spend $45,000 on a new car can’t even be bothered to answer the phone or reply to an email. Amazing… simply amazing.
My cruise with my Crazie friends is a mere 11 days away and the entire crew boarders on frenzy!! This is going to be one heck of an event!! I hope Kyle is ready for us!!
Please pass along my howdies to the lovely Heidi and Kye. See you soon.
Ciao!!
Host Mach
Hi John!
Peter’s interview was amazing. what a cool job refitting all these ships. I would love t hear more.
That is way too much info they asked on the hotel form.
I had read about the United flyer from last year. What a shame.
Hope you have a great day and take care!
David
John
Don said watching you dance once was enough. I just knew he would want to see it again.
Hugs to Kye who will never act like the litle heathens the pax had to put up with
Countess Carolyn………..16 days 17 hours 20 minutes until Carnival Holiday but who’s counting
Glad you 3 are seeing family in Holland. I am surprised though that you aren’t staying at Heidi’s mum’s house! Glad you made the trip to the cemetery, I KNOW Heidi’s dad was looking down with that twinkle in his eye looking at your beautiful girls, and then of cause he saw you and all the weight you lost- with a look of pride, and also that you and Heidi make wonderful parents. I am sure all of Heidi’s family are thrilled with KYE. See you in January. I see Frank & Bridie wrote to you too! Your friends, Linda & Mike
John:
If I have already told you this story…I apologize.
One of the most poignant moments as a Mother came when my then 11 year old son (Joshua) explained to another mother (of a devil child) that she was not doing her job correctly.
The mother of the devil child was “counting”…and as she got to about 19…another lady said…”counting does not work”.
This is when Joshua spoke up and said “Yes it does, if you do it correctly. My Mom uses the counting method…
ONE….TWO….UNCONCIOUS!!”
The point being that while I was always fair…both my sons understood that actions had consequences and since my consequences were usually extremely unpleasant… they never wanted to go there.
Now they are grown (21 and 18) without a minute of trouble…
They are not perfect…and I am very glad they are not. But they are fine young men that I am extremely proud of.
Raising children takes several things, but the most important is security and consistancy.
If children are raised to be truly valued, then they will grow into truly valuable adults.
Sadly today, to many children are not respected…therefore they grow up not being respectful. And my heart breaks for them.
Unfortunately, we can not change the world…so we only cruise when school is in session.
For someone cruising from the US, I would suggest September (after the 10th), October and November (before Thanksgiving), December (before Christmas) and January (after New Years) and the first part of February (before Presidents Day). We avoid March and April due to Spring Break but the first week or so of May is usually ok as well.
This will generally insure the least amount of children onboard.
Love the Country Western Song writer…. as I recall, the comedian Ron White did this about his experience with Sears over a set of tires. It was very effective.
Many thanks to Mr. Peter Fetten…we LOVE the Adult Serenity area on the Fantasy class ships. We hope that this kind of area is in the works for all the ships in the Carnival fleet.
Linda (Mom of your friend ~ who nevers runs on a ship unless there has been a Funship Freddie encounter~ DJ)
Dear John , well as the fall sets in , we are still reading your blog and dreaming of the Carnival Dream , we have been waiting for the winning of the lotto , but no luck . however the blog is entertaining and you keep us laughing . We have three teenagers and I now know just what my mother meant when she told me to stop. She was speaking from experience and she knew what I was in for , so yet again she has been right and I however will not tell her so , like always I think I know more only to be proven wrong ….. well heres to parenting . and really we canadians do not all sound like we are related to bob or doug and I do really wish that when Air Canada Lost our luggage we had made a video of the horrible and very big trouble it cost us . As we missed out on wearing all our nice clothing on the cruise we took , I remember the many walls and the lack of care air Canada had for us and our missing luggage , especially when the carry one cannot hold more than a toothbrush and one pair of clean underware . it was a night mare and the anniversathe comry, honeymoon we never had trip of a lifetime was ruined by their lossing our bags . I must say the shops on carnival are nice but they do not carry clothing to replace what we had lost , and once you are headed out its hard to find clothing in the middle of the ocean . So I guess we should have made a video of the things we missed out on – like formal dining on the cruise , which face it is part of the romance and planning of a cruise . and the whole thing is when you save money for the cruise to go on excursions and have to use it to buy replacement summer ware you have just bought – it really sucks . I hope United Way got the message and Maybe Air Canada will too . I would love to be able to redo that cruise and have all our things we spent months getting , and preparing , and really we were dissapointed . but hey life goes on and maybe one can dream of getting to go on another anniversary cruise – never know – but I will keep on buying the lotto ticket fr now .
have a good one
margo
thanks john, very kind of you to teach your darling child manners! if only everyone did!
prince charlie is so sick these days from the chemo, he is amazing though and says he will win the war! he has to, right? he shaved his head! looks pretty cute too…
smiles, bonnie and prince charlie
John, please reply:
Have you heard (or seen) anything about the new Sign and Sail cards yet? Looking forward to a picture if you can scrounge one up.
Thanks
Dear John,
If a Carnival Employee sees a kid doing something that they should not be doing, they should be allowed and empowered to take the hoolagan(s) to security and have their parents called over the intercom “Will Mr. and Mrs. Hoolagan come and get their child from the security department.” Once they show up let them know what their little darling was doing and notify them that if they have destroyed any property that they will be responsible for the cost of repairing it whether it be a scotter or a elevator door. They should be a little more watchful of their little darlings after that. If it happens again the whole family should be put ashore. I know that this sound a little rough but I am really tired of the few ruining things for the many. Parents are still legally responsible for their kids even at sea this doesn’t change.
Great interview with Peter. His job is one that has always amazed me. The organization that goes into a large project like this is mind boggling.
I agree with you too about the amount of forms that they want you to fill out now adays. Absurd! You don’t even have to give that information to Carnival for the world’s best vacation as long as you bring enough cash. It also amazes me that alot of places won’t accept cash now. Too much!
I hope you are not going to make us fill out forms like this for the man cave shore excursion.
James & Nancy
The Cruzin2some
Dear John,
I’m not sure if you have the time to read all the comments you get, but I did want to express how pleased I am with Carnival’s dedication to family cruising.
This past May, I enjoyed my fourth Carnival cruise, but my first cruise ever with a child. My husband, my 3-year-old daughter, my mom, our long-time family friend and I all sailed on the Carnival Glory Mothers’ Day week. I was a little nervous about my daughter’s first cruise, because she has apraxia, which is a motor planning delay. (Essentially, my daughter’s brain knows WHAT she wants to say, but can’t always get her tongue and mouth to form the words correctly, so speaking clearly is very difficult for her.)
I signed my daughter into Camp Carnival some days, and she absolutely loved the program because the counselors were so good and patient with her. As an added bonus, both my husband and I noticed a HUGE improvement in our daughter’s speech by the end of the week!
But the Camp Carnival counselors weren’t the only ones who made my daughter feel special. Every crew member we encounter smiled and said hello to my daughter and most called her “princess,” which really made her beam.
Our entire wait staff were also fabulous and doted on my daughter like she was a true princess. We had just one minor incident the second night of our cruise, in which the head waiter at the table next to ours accidentally stabbed my daughter with a dinner knife. I know sentences that end in “STABBED MY DAUGHTER with a dinner knife” don’t usually start with “just one minor incident,” so let me explain:
My daughter being 3 and excited to be on her first Carnival cruise with her parents and her favorite grandma, just could not keep still those first 2 nights. I succeeded for the most part in keeping her out of the aisles, but this particular evening, she couldn’t stand sitting across the table from her grandma and wanted to sit next to her grandma instead. After a few minutes of badgering from both parties involved, I gave my daughter permission to sit in the chair next to my mom.
Again, being 3 and excited to be on her first Carnival cruise, my daughter wasn’t watching where she was going (she was looking behind her) as she started walking around the table to the other side. Unfortunately, the head waiter at the table next to us had just cleared away some plates and utensils, including a dinner knife, and was standing in the aisle between the two tables with the dinner knife at his side and pointed away from him. Well, my daughter walked right into the point of the knife, and suffered a very small scratch on her shoulder. Actually, I wouldn’t even say it was a scratch…more like a red mark…because it didn’t even break the skin and was gone by the end of the cruise.
Anyway, the head waiter felt terrible (even though it wasn’t his fault) and tried to console my now crying daughter. We convinced her that it was just the tiniest of boo-boos and she settled down pretty quickly. Still, it seemed like nearly the entire dining room staff rushed over to tend to my daughter and make sure she was ok and well-supplied with cookies, chocolate milk, and ice cream.
John, I can’t tell you how impressed I was with how many of the Carnival staff showed that they genuinely cared about their tiny guest and they went above and beyond to make sure that she was ok!
In my opinion, Carnival has set the bar for family cruising, and my daughter is looking forward to our April cruise on the Carnival Inspiration and our May cruise on the Carnival Dream. She STILL talks about our cruise on the Carnival Glory, and for that I need to say a big “thank you, Carnival!” because anything that gets my daughter talking and practicing her speech is a wonderful thing!
Laura
John,
Thank you so much for posting the video for “United Breaks Guitars.” Our local radio station was talking about this a couple of weeks ago and played the song, which had me laughing out loud. I’d forgotten about it till you posted it, and now I get to share it with my hubby. Thanks!
John, please reply–I see that one of the ships mentioned today is being refitted for Carnival Australia. My question is, what is the relationship between Carnival and Carnival Australia? Are they sister companies like Holland America and Carnival (and therefore no transfer of “status” i.e. Platinum Guest) or since they are both named Carnival will traveling on one be the same as traveling on the other? (Planning ahead as Australia is on our bucket list and what better way to visit than on a Carnival cruise!) Thanks, Linda
I love the United video–yours is pretty funny too!
Now kids. I have sailed with and without them. At this point the grandchildren are not teens and therefore I wouldn’t think of allowing them off by themselves. I have witnessed dangerous behavior that I reported to security who told me that unless they witness it, there is nothing they can do. So, I agree there has to be more than one witness to a “wrong or dangerous behavior” but when there is there should be consequences for the teens involved. Largely I believe the crew is not empowered to stop them regardless of what they do. These particular boys on the Carnival Splendor forward pool climbed atop the guard rail to the hot tub that sided the pool and jumped from the rail into the pool while both were packed with people. Had they slipped and fell hitting their heads on something or striking another person, their parents would be demanding compensation from Carnival for damages for their injuries. There truly needs to be more vigilence by security especially during the months when the teen count is highest. Maybe you could make a naughty spot on the ship for those caught misbehaving.
I love the interview with Peter. I find all the refitting process totally fascinating.
Cheryl
Stephanie or John, please reply ASAP
Please tell me it is not true that the Nov 15th Bloggers cruise on the Dream has been canceled. I am behind in reading the blog so if it has been already addressed I am sorry for asking.
John,
I thought I’d let you all know about what happened to us on United Airlines. My daughter went to visit her brother in College when she was 12. We live in San Diego and her brother was in College at Sonoma State in Santa Rosa, Ca.. I paid extra for her to get escorted from one plane to the next. (She went from Santa Rosa, Ca. to San Francisco and on to San Diego) They put her on a plane to Chicago. Yes! They finally got her home and gave us $25 towards our next United Flight. We have not used that $25 because they did not take the situation seriously. I had been a flight attendent for American a long time ago and knew this was not acceptable. As they laughed and thougt it funny I decided never ever to fly with them again! And I haven’t! She is now 27 with two children of her own and she will never fly United!
JOHN PLEASE REPLY,
Your blogs are funny even when you’re not a CD.
There are always 2 songs that every Carnival ship plays during dinner. One is Tina Turner’s Simply the Best which signals the end of the cruise……BOO HOO
and the other one is ?????? For the life of me, I can never remember the darn song except it has the word “girl” in it…..LOL
Help please! Thanks, JOHN
Cindy
John: (Please reply)
A question has come up on Cruise Critic that I thought was interesting.
How many Platinum members does Carnival have?
We have a running list on Cruise Critic that is current just short of 300 “units”. (that could be a single person, a couple or a family like us)
I know this number probably changes daily, but it would be interesting to know.
Thanks
Linda (Mom of your friend DJ)
John please reply…
Hi, John!
How have you, Heidi & Kye enjoyed your Holland vacation? We guess it’s soon coming to an end… We bet Heidi’s family has gone crazy about beautiful Kye!
On our Aug. 30 message to you published on your 8/28 blog (we are waiting for your reply) we made a typo error…. We typed that on the cruises 2+ days…. Instead it should say: on cruises 12+ days Carnival should consider changing their policy and credit the people taking them as earning two credits instead of one. Sorry for the typo numerical error!
We know that you are behind replying to all of the many requests/questions/comments, so in the meantime we patiently wait for your reply to our Aug. 30 message…. it contains a few items we already had previously written to you about but we never received a reply, so we believe that maybe the earlier ones got lost in cyber space….
We hope that you have a nice trip back home from Holland to England and also wish you a nice trip to Italy to join the Dream….
We are looking forward to our Nov. 21 Freedom cruise!
The Santanas of Miami Beach
John,
Great hearing from you, as always, mate–oops, that’s your line.
I was gratified to see Dave Carroll’s video; all too often these things happen, and nothing is said. The airlines, or other similar service industries, get away with it while we slink away with our collective tails tucked between our legs. Bravo to Dave for exacting his “pound of flesh” for their indifferent reactions to his concern not just over his loss of a prized possession, but the loss of an implement vital to his career.
John, I just wanted to take a moment to comment on the last photo of Kye you posted. She is so beautiful. I can’t help but notice how much she looks like Heidi, and how she uses that gorgeous smile to get whatever she wants from her Dad–just like Heidi, I suspect. I see th same pouty lip that when applied to Heidi, means you are headed to maison de chien (dog house in French). But most of all, when I look at her smile, I see a glimmer of the photo you posted of Heidi’s dad, and I suspect you are once again glad to have that reminder of the person you so admired.
Best to all of you–try to enjoy your time on terra firma.
John,
Thanks so much for the videos I browsed through yours and found the bedtime story. I haven’t laughed that hard since the movie The Hangover. It was hilarious made my day. I really hope to sail with you some day.
Kim
John………please respond.
Counting down the days until we board the Carnival Dream at Port Canaveral on December 3rd, like so many others!
Just wondering how many cruise elegant nights there will be on this 9 night cruise?
(John – Please Notice)
Hi John, Linda and I have decided to sail on the Dream for December 3 after the exaustion of moving our offices to a new modern home port for us. As that is the bloggers cruise, we would love for you to include us in the festivities. Thanks in advance – and Linda and I will see you then. And I insist, this time, that you and some others find a night (as our guest) in the Steak House.
Glen & Linda
GalaxSea Cruises
John,
I just wanted to tell you how much my husband and I enjoyed you on the Freedom (8/1-8/8). You are the best cruise director we have ever had and were a major reason why we had such a wonderful cruise. I called Carnival and told them they had better do everything they can to make you happy, so that you will always stay with them. We laughed so hard at the evening shows because of your quick whit. The morning shows were a great way to start our day and we never missed them. Can’t wait until our next cruise with you! Fondly, Mary A.
The is no doubt in my mind that your blog is one of the rare treasures on the Internet. I am referring all my Mafia friends (on Facebook) to you.
John- Please Reply-
You don’t have to reply in the blog, I just wanted to make sure you saw this. If you do post to the blog, please hide the booking number details.
I wrote to you back in July about our upcoming Valor cruise. I said that this was my sister’s first Carnival cruise and I was hoping you could help make it a special one so she would be impressed with Carnival’s value. She said she hoped we would get a window table. I realize that is a popular request but you said you would see what you could do. You said to write back about 2 weeks before our cruise… well its 2 weeks before our cruise so here I am!
We have 2 cabins and the bookings are “linked” for dinning, but the bookings are for the 9/27/09 sailing of Carnival Valor.
I thank you in advance for anything you can do for us. If that becomes “nothing” I won’t be upset as I know I am asking you to do something above and beyond your duties.
I hope all is well with Heidi, Kye and yourself. Keep the pictures of Kye coming, she looks like such a sweetheart. And yes… I have booked my Carnival Dream ….and I can’t wait for that cruise which will be our first Platinum cruise!
Jim
Hi John,
Farewell party is being rolled out fleetwide Sept 12. I was hoping this would not come to be. So no more free drinks at the Captain’s party. It would be interesting to see how much the attendance numbers are going to drop.
Dave
I loved the United video! Thanks for posting it.
This is another example of what effect bad customer service can have on a company.
I agree with one of the bloggers when they said unruly kids should be taken into “custody” by security, and if they continue to get into trouble (and the parents refuse to do anything about it) deport them. It is a shame to have a much anticipated vacation ruined by some hoodlums.
Keep up the good work John.
John Please reply
Hi John
As our Oct 3rd sailing date on the Carnival Dream draws closer I fall asleep with questions..Last nights was ..We have booked a wrap aft balcony cabin # 8466….will there be a lounger on the balcony? Just wondering as my other half loves to lie out!!
thanks..and we cant wait to see her ourselves!!
Mel
John, I just watched your dance video, you are a very sick man. I hope you and the family are having fun, you deserve it. A nice long rest. Get some help for that leg problem. God bless.
John,
Everytime I hear “Holland” I still instead think of Mr.Yabba Dabba Doo! That was the best ever!